If you need sauce for your meals, then you can enjoy fresh ingredients and have the control over the flavor and texture of your meal by making your own tomato sauce. When making tomato sauce, opt for a stainless steel kitchen tool to ensure smooth, tasty sauce without unnecessary seeds and skins.
A food mill is one of the most convenient pieces of stainless steel equipment when shopping for tomato sauce. It is used to separate tomato skins and seeds, and to create a smooth or chunky sauce, depending on which disc you use. For those who love cooking at home and making sauces, purees, jams and other homemade dishes, stainless steel food mills are extremely useful.
We are going to compare three kitchen tools in this guide – the OXO Good Grips Stainless Steel Food Mill, Hungry Artisan 3-Disc Food Mill and the OXO Good Grips 4 Cup Fat Separator. Each of the E.ach products has a different use and knowing what the features are can assist you in selecting the correct one for your kitchen.
Quick Comparison Table
| Product | Main Purpose | Key Features | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| OXO Good Grips Stainless Steel Food Mill | Grinding and straining cooked foods | Three stainless steel discs, 2.3-quart capacity, non-slip legs | Homemade tomato sauce |
| Hungry Artisan 3-Disc Food Mill | Making sauces and purees | Stainless steel construction, three texture options, manual crank | Tomato sauce and canning |
| OXO Good Grips 4 Cup Fat Separator | Separating fat from cooking liquids | Built-in strainer, measurement markings, stopper | Gravy, broth, and cooking liquids |
OXO Good Grips Stainless Steel Food Mill
For a home cook who prefers making their own tomato sauce without all the hassle, the OXO Good Grips Stainless Steel Food Mill is an easy-to-use option. It is made of stainless steel with grinding discs, which can be used for cooking tomatoes and other soft foods.
The food mill has three discs of various sizes to help you grind it fine, medium or coarse. Useful for preparing a smooth pasta sauce, rustic tomato sauce or thicker puree.
It has a capacity of some 2.3 quarts and is good for moderate-sized batches. Three non-slip legs hold the mill up above bowls and pots up to 11 inches in diameter so there is no processed food underneath.
Key Features
- Stainless steel bowl: Food processor bowl, plastic exterior to protect hands from heat.
- Three different grinding discs: Make fine, medium or coarse textured foods for various recipes.
- Spring loaded lever: Easier to change discs and disassemble mill.
- Non-slip legs: Assist in maintaining the mill’s stability on appropriate bowls and pots.
- 2.3 quarts capacity: Good for making homemade sauces and purees.
Pros
- Offers three texture options.
- Stainless steel grinding discs can be used for multiple food preparation.
- Non-slip legs for added stability.
- Great for tomato sauce, purees and other soft cooked foods.
- The lever is spring-loaded, making disc changes easier.
Cons
- Needs physical work to be used.
- When dealing with extremely large harvests it may be a limitation in its capacity.
- It is best to cook or soften tomatoes before milling.
Ideal for: Home cooks who need a versatile food mill that can be used for making tomato sauce and other recipes.
Hungry Artisan 3-Disc Food Mill
For the folks who like cooking their own tomato sauce, there’s some additional choices that include the Hungry Artisan 3-Disc Food Mill. It is manual crank, so it’s convenient to do the food processing without electricity, which is suitable for daily cooking and home canning preparation.
Mill has a stainless steel body, discs and crank. It comes with three interchangeable disks for coarse, medium, fine textures, so you can tweak the texture of your tomato sauce as per the recipe.
In addition to tomato sauce, this food mill can be used to make applesauce, baby food, mashed potatoes, purees and jam bases. It is also quite versatile and can be used in kitchens where homemade food is made fairly often.
Key Features
- Repeated use construction: Body, Discs and crank are made of stainless steel.
- Three interchangeable discs: Give choices of food textures.
- Manual rotary crank: Can be used without electricity.
- Multiple uses: Use for tomato sauce, applesauce, purees and soft foods.
- Easy to use for canning: Assists in processing cooked foods at home.
Pros
- Does not need electricity to operate.
- Allows 3 different texture settings.
- Ideal for more than tomatoes!
- Stainless steel components are intended for multiple use.
- Great for home cooks who want to can seasonal produce.
Cons
- Manually operating can be time consuming if dealing with lots of items.
- Product information provided does not indicate the capacity of the product.
- When making a large quantity of sauce it may be necessary to prepare in batches.
Ideal for: Home cooks looking to have a manual food mill for tomato sauce, applesauce, purees and for any other seasonal foods.
OXO Good Grips 4 Cup Fat Separator
The OXO Good Grips 4 Cup Fat Separator is not intended for use in food mills as the two previously mentioned food mills. It is not for grinding tomatoes or separating the tomato skins and seeds but to separate fat from cooking liquids like gravy and broth.
It has a built-in strainer to catch unwanted food particles, and a pouring control stopper to help control the flow of the liquid. The raised shield prevents splashing and measurement markings make it simple to measure liquids for recipes.
It may be of assistance in kitchens that make tomato based meals at home but it is not to be used to make tomato sauce from fresh tomatoes.
Key Features
- Inbuilt strainer: to catch unwanted parts of cooking juices.
- Stopper: Helps keep unwanted material out while pouring.
- Raised shield: Helps reduce spills and splashes.
- Measurement markings: Make it easier to measure liquids accurately.
- Non-slip handle: Gives a non-slip grip.
- Stopper storage: It retains the stopper in the strainer when it is not being used.
Pros
- Good for removing fat from gravy and broth.
- Fitted with strainer that removes unwanted particles.
- Markings help to ensure precise cooking.
- Easy to pour with comfortable handle.
- Stopper storage helps to hold the components in place.
Cons
- Will not crush tomatoes or peel and pit them, such as with a food mill.
- Is used for a different purpose than the other two products.
- Product information does not imply that it is completely stainless steel.
Best for: Home cooks who frequently use gravy, broth and cooking liquids, and need a fat separator.
Also read;Industrial Food Mill: 2 Best Electric Food Mills for Smooth Sauces and Easy Food Processing
Buying Guide:
When purchasing a kitchen tool to make tomato sauce at home, you should take into account the frequency of sauce production, the smoothness of the product and the volume of food for which you need to process.
Select a Food Mill for Tomato Sauce.
When you want to make the sauce from cooked tomatoes, but you want to get rid of the skins and seeds, a food mill is typically the best option. Can save time as opposed to pushing tomatoes through a sieve.
If you want a specific capacity and a design that does not change, the OXO Good Grips Stainless Steel Food Mill is something that you should look into. If you prefer a manual mill with all stainless steel components, you can also choose the Hungry Artisan model.
Check the Stainless Steel Construction
Due to its durability and ease of upkeep with proper care, stainless steel is a favorite material for kitchenware. Do not assume that all parts of a product are made of the same material, ask which parts are stainless steel.
The OXO food mill features a stainless steel bowl and a protective plastic shell, whereas the Hungry Artisan type is said to have a stainless steel body, discs and crank.
Consider Texture Options
Various recipes require different consistency. Fine setting will yield a smoother sauce, medium or coarse setting will yield a more textured sauce.
This comparison of food mills includes 3 disc choices in each. If you cook a variety of different sauces, purees and other dishes, this will help you.
Look at Capacity
Capacity is a factor in processing a large number of tomatoes. If your mill is larger you’ll have less batches to prepare, but be sure to fit snugly over your pots or bowls.
The OXO Good Grips Stainless Steel Food Mill holds about 2.3 quarts. The information provided does not include a capacity for the Hungry Artisan mill, so please review the current Amazon listing before buying.
Consider Manual Effort
Food mills are hand- operated in both cases. They are not electrical powered, and you may need to process a large batch; that can be time-consuming and labor-intensive.
An occasional tomato sauce cooker may suffice if you only use the sauce occasionally. When you will be harvesting a lot regularly, check the capacity, ease of handling and handling comfort before you make your decision.
Know how to use a food mill and fat separator.
A food mill is used to make soft cooked foods and can be used to remove tomato skins and seeds from the pulp. The purpose of a fat separator is to remove fat from cooking liquids.
The OXO Good Grips 4 Cup Fat Separator can be helpful for gravy or broths, but is not the first choice to use when making tomato sauce from fresh tomato.
Check Cleaning and Care Instructions
Be aware of the cleaning guidelines from the manufacturer prior to purchase. While removable discs can help to simplify the cleaning process of food mills, it should be verified from the current product instructions to ensure that they are suitable for the dishwasher.
Frequently asked questions
Which tool will be best to use to make tomato sauce in stainless steel?
A stainless steel food mill is a good choice for creating homemade tomato sauce. Both the OXO Good Grips Stainless Steel Food Mill and Hungry Artisan 3-Disc Food Mill have three texture choices and can be used for soft food.
Is a food mill able to de-seed and peel tomatoes?
Yes. As you turn the crank, a food mill will remove most of the tomatoes’ seeds and skin. This will vary depending upon the tomatoes, the disc used, and the method of preparation.
When using a food mill, do I have to peel the tomatoes first?
Usually, no. One of the greatest advantages of a food mill is to be able to remove the tomato skins and seeds from the fruit during processing. Preparing the tomatoes by cooking or softening usually helps them to be easier to mill.
Yes, stainless steel is suitable for making tomato sauce.
Stainless steel is a great material to use for kitchen utensils, because it’s easy to clean and strong. If you are preparing tomato sauce, make sure to review the material and care information for your food mill.
What are the different sizes of food mill discs?
Medium-sized discs tend to have a smooth texture and a medium to fine texture, whereas fine discs have a smooth texture and a fine texture. Coarse discs will produce a chunkier look. This will depend on the recipe you’re using and your taste.
Can I use other foods in the Hungry Artisan 3-Disc Food Mill?
Yes. Its supplied product information specifies that it can be used for applesauce, mashed potatoes, baby foods, purees, jam bases and tomato sauces.
Can the OXO Good Grips 4 Cup Fat Separator be used to make tomato sauce?
It was not meant to be used for making tomatoes or removing their skins and seeds. It is used mainly to separate fat from cooking liquids, such as gravy and broth.
Final Verdict
When selecting a tool for tomato sauce in stainless steel, one must take into account their own cooking requirements.
OXO Good Grips Stainless Steel Food Mill offers an excellent option for home cooks who need three texture options, a claimed capacity of 2.3 quarts, and legs that have a grip on any food mill that is compatible with the bowl or pot they are using.
A manual stainless steel mill like the Hungry Artisan 3-Disc Food Mill is a good option for tomato sauce, applesauce, purees, and other home cooking.
The other kitchen chore for which the OXO Good Grips 4 Cup Fat Separator comes in handy is to separate fat from gravy and broth. If you are aiming for fresh tomato sauce, it is not the best option.
We recommend using a food mill instead of a fat separator if you would like to make tomato sauce without seeds or skins. To determine which food mill is best for your budget, batch size and cooking schedule, check the 2 food mills you are considering on Amazon.
Also read;Best Cheese Toasty Maker in 2026: 3 Top Sandwich Presses Reviewed